Fat Renee Or Skinny Renee?

July 2007 Renee Zellweger recently showed up at an awards show in Beverly Hills looking as thin as a No. 2 pencil. We can't help but conjure up images of the voluptuous and curvy body she sported in the "Bridget Jones'" films. Our panel weighs in (no pun intended) on which we like better, big Renee or skinny Renee?

Sharon Moore "She starved herself, and for what? I thought she was really attractive in "Bridget Jones Diary." Her puffy face was charming and beautiful. Now, her face is taut and drawn. I don't like her new appearance. The waif look might work for Nicole Ritchie, but not Renee."

Anita Star "I like her new look. Very elegant and disciplined. You can tell she is working out incredibly hard. If it makes her feel good, then more power to her." We'll buy that, Anita.

Sharon Moore "I think she's pretty either way. This new super skinny look is just as sexy as when she was a little more on the curvy Rachel Ray side. The point is not to shy away from your beauty, and I don't think she does. If she wants to be skinny, that's fine – if she wants to go over the top – well, that's her choice, too."